A banner reads "College Football Playoff on ESPN" and features the CFP logo.
Starting with the 2027-28 college football season, the College Football Playoff will increase to 24 teams, up from a 12 team slate that began in the 2024 season and a 4 team playoff that replaced the BCS in 2014. The new format will aware automatic bids to the champions of the Power 4 conferences, a single spot awarded to the highest rank Group of 6 team, and 19 at-large participants. The top eight teams will receive a first round bye, with teams 9-16 and 1-8 hosting in the first two rounds, quarterfinals and semifinals taking place in the New Years Six bowls, and the championship going to an awarded site. As with all things college football, opinions on the change vary, though there's significant discourse on the value of the regular season and the ease (relatively speaking) of inclusion for certain teams, even with multiple losses.

I'll start by saying this: I've never viewed college football through the lens of the championship. It's not integral to my enjoyment of what I believe to be the greatest sport in the world, and my own fanhood puts access squarely out of reach anyway. With that said, I've always been interested in all the adjacent machinations that make the sport go, and certainly the playoff and championship structure - and the network puppetmastering that makes it go - is a big part of that. 

Let's first be clear: the primary - dare I say, near-sole - motivation for the move is financial. There's no particular entitlement to access that teams that end the season ranked 13-24 should have. But 24 teams being involved, with several more surviving late into the season with opportunities to make the field, interests more fan bases in the sport, and more casual fans who primary interest is the championship structure. 

Personally, I'm agnostic as to the exact number. What does concern me, however, is that nearly all or all of the at-large spots will go to power conference teams and Notre Dame each year. What the expanded playoff does not do is expand access for teams that don't already have access through conference affiliation. Any P4 team has the ability to play themselves in in any given year, especially with the expanded field. Group of Six teams can do everything right and still fall short, and the change in format does little to change that. And while the common argument is that those teams are unable to truly compete, the same can be said for the back half of the 24 team field. And even where the can compete, they've already fallen short of earning their way in in previous iterations. 

There are a few things that excite me about the new format. First round games came to campuses when the field expanded to 12, and this format doubles down, including hosting opportunities for the teams with a first round bye, who go straight to the bowls in the current format. This means 16 campus-based playoff games in December before the later stages move to bowl sites around New Year's Eve/Day. And while I've not heard this said, the Rose Bowl will likely hold on to permanent quarterfinal placement, keeping their kickoff at 2pm Pacific on New Year's Day and, just as importantly, keeping the Rose Parade intact.

In the new format, the season will stretch from the weekend before Labor Day weekend - the previous "Week Zero" until Thanksgiving weekend - rivalry week, for many. Conference championship games will no longer exist, with the championships being awards via each conference's respective rules and in some cases, an endless string of tiebreakers. Army/Navy will stand along the first Saturday in December, and the first round will get underway the week that follows - sometime around my birthday. What's not yet been stated is what will become of the bowls as we know them. There will, of course, be fewer eligible teams outside of the playoff structure, and they'll be further diminished by an attention structure focused primarily on the playoffs. It'll be up to ESPN - who, let's be honest, is pulling the strings in all of this - whether or not any continue. Knowing that there are a good deal of teams who will never have access to the playoff who will still see a bowl berth as a reward for a successful season, it would be unfortunate to see them go. 

Which, of course, brings me to another implication of the expanded playoff: The bands.

Starting with the effect on bowl season as we know it: Fewer bowl opportunities for those outside of the playoff structure means that some bands will miss out on the bowl game experience and the trip, camaraderie, and opportunity to support the team that comes with it. 

The expanded playoff also puts additional games on participants, with a team who plays in the first round playing five games in five difference locations should they reach the championship game. Will schools maintain their commitment to send the entire marching band to each and every game? Or will they "opt out" and send pared down units for earlier rounds? I'd like to think, both in service to the band and support of the team, that the full band every time would never be considered a doubt, but I can also acknowledge that mobilizing 300+ band members and their instruments, often with less than two weeks' notice and to less-than-cosmopolitan locations, can prove difficult and expensive. For that matter, opportunities for the band are an allegory of opportunities for fans, who will have to choose if and how they can support their team through such a run.

Since the playoff began, we've seen bands repeat field shows in consecutive rounds. It's practical - much of the playoff occurs during break periods, giving little opportunity to learn and clean a new show in advance of the next round of action. This may be frustrating for fans, who get to see the band previous few times on television, but can with streaming options during the playoff. But with the championship now pushing into the spring semester, might we see new shows by the championship game?

Or will we see bands perform at the championship game at all? Thankfully, save for off-site performances, the machine hasn't tried to pull this one yet, but as they go all-in on a more-than-a-billion-dollar playoff format, might the College Football Playoff try to go the Super Bowl route and bring in a major recording office, pre-empting a marching band halftime as the Good Lord intended? To do such would be a major swipe at the tradition of the sport, but as moves have taught us to this point, nothing is sacred.

Comments